If you’re Gen Z or a Millennial, climate change has been part of your life since grade school. You’ve heard it all: melting ice caps, rising sea levels, and the end of the world as we know it. Climate anxiety is now baked into your generation’s mindset.
But here’s a question worth asking: Is the climate crisis as extreme as you’ve been told?
Let’s look at what the science and history actually show—and why it’s smart to question alarmist narratives.
Climate Change Isn’t New—It’s Normal
The idea of climate change sounds like a modern emergency, but the Earth’s climate has always changed. Long before cars or carbon emissions, there were major swings in temperature.
During the Medieval Warm Period (950–1250 AD), global temperatures rose and agriculture expanded across Europe. Then came the Little Ice Age (1300–1850 AD), with advancing glaciers, harsh winters, and food shortages.
None of that was caused by humans. So the assumption that today’s warming is entirely man-made needs a closer look.
Greenland Ice Cores Reveal the Real Climate Story
Deep in Greenland’s ice are trapped air bubbles, particles, and isotopes that hold a detailed record of Earth’s climate for nearly 800,000 years. Scientists use these ice cores to understand how the climate has naturally shifted over time.
Here’s what they’ve found: Earth’s climate used to be wildly unstable. Massive temperature swings of 5 to 10 degrees Celsius happened within just a few decades. But for the last 11,700 years—the Holocene epoch—we’ve lived in a rare period of climate stability.
That stability is the exception, not the norm. It also happens to be the period when human civilization developed. So when people say today’s climate is “unprecedented,” it makes sense to ask—compared to what?
CO₂ Isn’t Always the Driver
Another insight from the ice cores: CO₂ doesn’t consistently lead temperature change. In many warming periods, temperature increased first, and CO₂ followed hundreds of years later. That suggests CO₂ may be a feedback effect, not the trigger.
As physicist Dr. William Happer explains, warming often causes CO₂ to rise—not the other way around. That challenges the mainstream assumption that CO₂ is the primary climate control knob.
Also worth noting: There have been periods throughout earth’s past where CO₂ levels were higher than today, long before humans entered the picture. For example, during the Eocene Epoch around 50 million years ago, CO₂ levels may have been more than twice what they are now. Yet life on Earth flourished.
Why This Matters for Young People
If you’re under 40, your understanding of climate change likely comes from recent trends. But when you zoom out and look at the full history, the story changes.
The planet has been both much hotter and much colder than it is today. Climate shifts have happened fast, without any human involvement. And the relatively stable period we’re in now? That’s the real outlier.
So when media or politicians claim we’re in an unprecedented crisis, they’re often ignoring the bigger picture.
Mass Extinctions Were the Real Climate Disasters
When people talk about a “climate catastrophe,” most imagine modern temperature changes or rising sea levels. But if you really want to see what planetary collapse looks like, look at the five mass extinction events in Earth’s history. These weren’t slow shifts—they were global reset buttons.
1. Ordovician–Silurian Extinction (Around 445 million years ago)
This was Earth’s first known mass extinction. It happened in two waves and wiped out about 85% of marine species.
What triggered it? A sudden ice age. Glaciers expanded, sea levels dropped, and shallow marine habitats disappeared. This killed off corals, trilobites, and many early sea creatures.
No human influence. No carbon emissions. Just nature doing its thing.
2. Late Devonian Extinction (About 375 million years ago)
Roughly 75% of all species vanished, most of them marine life.
Scientists believe this one was caused by massive volcanic eruptions that disrupted ocean chemistry. The oceans lost oxygen which suffocated marine ecosystems. Coral reefs collapsed.
The land wasn’t safe either—early plants may have changed the soil and atmosphere, altering carbon levels. It was complex, and it didn’t involve people.
3. Permian–Triassic Extinction (252 million years ago)
Nicknamed “The Great Dying”, this was the worst extinction in Earth’s history. Around 96% of marine life and 70% of land speciesdisappeared.
The cause? Massive volcanic eruptions in Siberia led to global warming, ocean acidification, and widespread oxygen loss in the sea.
It was so severe that it took millions of years for ecosystems to recover. Forests turned to deserts. Reefs vanished. Even insects took a hit.
4. Triassic–Jurassic Extinction (201 million years ago)
This event wiped out about 80% of species, clearing the way for dinosaurs to rise.
Massive volcanic activity again played a role. The Earth got hotter. Sea levels rose. Species couldn’t adapt fast enough.
It wasn’t gradual—it was violent, fast, and global.
5. Cretaceous–Paleogene Extinction (66 million years ago)
This is the one you’ve definitely heard of—the asteroid that killed the dinosaurs. But it did much more. Around 75% of all species went extinct.
The asteroid impact near modern-day Mexico triggered wildfires, blocked sunlight with dust clouds, and caused a sudden drop in global temperatures.
In just a few months, photosynthesis shut down. Plants died. Food chains collapsed. The age of dinosaurs ended—and mammals took over.
What Today’s Changes Look Like in Context
Now compare those events to what we’re seeing today: a 1–2°C increase in average temperature over the past century, and gradual sea level rise of a few millimeters per year.
That’s not extinction-level. It’s not even close.
We’re not seeing mass die-offs of species on a global scale. We’re not experiencing sudden, system-wide collapse. We’re seeing change—but not apocalypse.
Understanding real mass extinctions helps put today’s climate discussion into perspective. It reminds us that Earth has been through far worse—and it also reminds us that the current narrative often leaves out the scale and speed of actual planetary disasters.
Science Is Still Political
Science should be about asking questions. But researchers also face pressure—whether from funding, peer review, or public expectations.
In 2023, climate scientist Dr. Patrick T. Brown admitted to omitting key factors from a wildfire study so the paper would get published. He left out data on forest management because he knew it would be rejected otherwise.
Other scientists, like Judith Curry and Roger Pielke Jr., have also spoken about censorship and bias in climate research.
It’s fair to trust science. It’s also fair to ask who benefits from the version of science that makes the headlines.
Failed Climate Predictions Keep Coming
Some of the most extreme climate predictions haven’t just missed the mark—they’ve completely flopped.
Al Gore said the Arctic would be ice-free by 2013. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez warned in 2019 that we had 12 years left. A UN official predicted coastal cities would be underwater by 2000. Dr. David Viner once claimed children “won’t know what snow is.”
None of those came true. But they continue to influence policy, media, and public fear.
If a private company made these kinds of false predictions, they’d go out of business. In climate politics, they just get more funding.
Green Energy: Who Really Profits?
Green energy sounds like a moral crusade, but it’s also a trillion-dollar industry. In 2023, governments gave out over $1.3 trillion in green subsidies. That’s a strong incentive to keep the crisis narrative alive.
Critics call it the climate-industrial complex—a web of corporations, NGOs, and lawmakers all profiting from public fear. It’s worth asking whether we’re being sold solutions to a problem that’s been inflated.
Being Skeptical Isn’t Denial
You can care about the planet and still question the hype.
Supporting clean air, clean water, and innovation doesn’t mean you have to buy into every apocalyptic claim. It means thinking critically, demanding better evidence, and refusing to be manipulated.
Skepticism is part of science. Fear isn’t a substitute for facts.
The Earth Isn’t Fragile—We Are
Earth is 4.5 billion years old. It’s survived asteroid impacts, supervolcanoes, and mass extinctions. It will survive us.
The bigger question is whether we’ll survive the choices we make in response to fear. Rebuilding society around a crisis narrative without questioning it? That might be the real threat.
The Bottom Line
Yes, the climate is changing. Yes, we should be smart about how we use resources. But no, we don’t have to panic.
Leave a Reply